24 May 2012, 20:58:48 *

Login with username, password and session length
Welcome to War and Tactics!    War and Tactics Forum has been heavily streamlined to help you find your place of interest faster. Hope you like it!
   
  Home   Forum   Help ! Forum Rules ! Search Calendar Donations Login Register Chat  
Pages: [1]   Go Down
  Print  
Share this topic on Del.icio.usShare this topic on DiggShare this topic on FacebookShare this topic on GoogleShare this topic on MySpaceShare this topic on RedditShare this topic on StumbleUponShare this topic on TechnoratiShare this topic on TwitterShare this topic on Yahoo
Author Topic: Book Review: "Kiss the Boys Goodbye" (How the US betrayed it's own POWs in Viet  (Read 1094 times)
FACman
WaT Supporter

*

Offline Offline

United States

Location: Ar-kansas
Posts: 827




View Profile
« on: 7 August 2009, 15:51:26 »
ReplyReply

"Kiss the Boys Goodbye" by Monika Jensen-Stevenson & William Stevenson

This book is about a devastating American scandal. In 'Kiss the Boys Goodbye', two award winning journalists provide startling evidence that the American government, right up to it's highest echelons, knows, and has always known, that American POWs were left behind at the end of the war. More amazingly, it has regularly obstructed the efforts of private citizens to discover the truth.

A sad tale which ripped my heart. But for the grace of god, it could have been about me and my family. Shame on America!

Published by Penguin Group (Dutton)

ISBN: 0-525-24934-6
Logged

"You can call me by my first name...Sarge."
the_13th_redneck
Sergeant Major
**

Offline Offline

Korea, Republic of

Location: on someone else's beach
Posts: 264




View Profile WWW
« Reply #1 on: 3 October 2009, 03:59:49 »
ReplyReply

I think bulldog also read this book.
Logged

Tanker
Sergeant Major
**

Offline Offline

United States

Posts: 223


View Profile
« Reply #2 on: 3 October 2009, 06:27:53 »
ReplyReply

I think it's important to read these reviews of this book on Amazon to get a balanced picture.

http://www.amazon.com/Kiss-Boys-Goodbye-Betrayed-Vietnam/product-reviews/0525249346/ref=cm_cr_pr_link_next_3?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=0&pageNumber=3
Logged
FACman
WaT Supporter

*

Offline Offline

United States

Location: Ar-kansas
Posts: 827




View Profile
« Reply #3 on: 7 November 2009, 07:00:43 »
ReplyReply

Quote
Tanker sez: I think it's important to read these reviews of this book on Amazon to get a balanced picture.


Having read all the reviews in your link, I would have to agree. Both sides of the argument are covered well. Though I still see no reason to think the Vietnamese wouldn't treat our POWs the same as the French POWs (the Pearls as the Vietnamese called them) they kept for so many years until ransom was paid.
Logged

"You can call me by my first name...Sarge."
Tanker
Sergeant Major
**

Offline Offline

United States

Posts: 223


View Profile
« Reply #4 on: 7 November 2009, 20:12:22 »
ReplyReply

Quote
Tanker sez: I think it's important to read these reviews of this book on Amazon to get a balanced picture.


Having read all the reviews in your link, I would have to agree. Both sides of the argument are covered well. Though I still see no reason to think the Vietnamese wouldn't treat our POWs the same as the French POWs (the Pearls as the Vietnamese called them) they kept for so many years until ransom was paid.


Perhaps, but the book, according to those reviews, does not offer any new or concrete evidence to support the sensational blurb in your first post.
Logged
FACman
WaT Supporter

*

Offline Offline

United States

Location: Ar-kansas
Posts: 827




View Profile
« Reply #5 on: 7 November 2009, 21:25:20 »
ReplyReply

Quote
Tanker sez: Perhaps, but the book, according to those reviews, does not offer any new or concrete evidence to support the sensational blurb in your first post


That my review is subjective goes without saying, however, to call it sensational may be a bit of a stretch...to that end I will include a few cuts from the reviewers you cite in your link, so that our readers can decide for themselves. I chose to only include reviews wherein the reviewers identified themselves by name.

Quote
This is a book that should make ordinary American citizens exceedingly sad and angry. Although some may argue that its message is old news, and certainly very dated information, the horror and outrage it should occasion is neither old nor dated. For what the authors contend, and go on to impressively prove, is that our national government deliberately and maliciously betrayed its own soldiers trapped as Prisoners Of War (POWs) in Vietnam, abandoning them in favor of a quick and otherwise painless exit from the war in Southeast Asia.
Barron Laycock


Quote
The book is not only a "good read," it also contains a wealth of important information that no researcher of the Pow/MIA issue can do without. The author has gone to exhaustive lengths in the detailing of this American tragedy.
Michael J Woznicki


Quote
I would highly recommend this book to everyone who would like a truthful explanation on the fate of our POW's, what has been hidden from the public by our govenment, and the illegal use of power by our govenment and it's intelligence agencies.
Kyle Tolle


Quote
This tells to whole story...how could we as civilized people forget some of the bravest men Amarica has produced?? I was in the Army, 67-70 and I am totally ashamed to be an American...she tells to facts, and you can decide how it effects you.
Victor R. Mcleod


Quote
What an outstanding book, truth always is better than the lies told by our Government having retired from the Government and knowing the inside facts of the fate of our POW/MIA's I testified UNDER OATH at the Senate POW/MIA hearing's and know first hand the truth this is a book for all to read it is History of how our elected "Cowards" run in the face of the enemy. five stars +++++ Truth is better than cover up
Scott Barnes


Quote
Mr and Mrs Stevenson have been on hundreds
of radio and TV shows and this very solidly
refferenced book should be on the same shelf
in your library as Col. James Bo Gritz books,
on the same subject [Ex: 'A Nation Betrayed'].
Bravo, Mr and Mrs Stevenson!
Richard A. Salzer


Quote
Aside from its "mysterious" and "too dangerous" so-called sources, the book is full of outright lies. To cite just one example, Jensen makes a very big deal out of the "mysterious" crash of an EC-47. The book claims that the EC-47 was "an aircraft designed to be a death trap" and that the crew was "compelled to commit war crimes." She also claims that "Because of the sophisticated electronic equipment on board, arrangements existed for the immolation and destruction of the aircraft before it could fall into enemy hands. The electronic equipment was packed in so tightly that it was almost impossible for men to bail out." All of that is just plain not true. Not one word of it. Nobody was forced to do anything. I was a navigator instructor on EC-47s at the same base in Thailand. We were just doing a job, and a pretty good one, compared to some of the idiotic schemes tried in SEA. There was plenty of room: more room than flying in coach these days. And the idea of a self-destruct mechanism on an ancient Gooney Bird is just plain laughable. Conspiracy theorists will love this book, but Ms. Jensen only perpetuates the myth that there are POWs still alive, which again would be laughable if it weren't so sad that families are still being used by scam artists like Ms. Jensen.
D. Steiner




 23 Reviews as compiled at the site linked to, ie; Amazon.com
5 star:     (15)
4 star:     (3)
3 star:     (1)
2 star:     (0)
1 star:     (4)

as you can see, 65% of the reviews rated the book at 5 stars (highest rating).






« Last Edit: 8 November 2009, 05:01:14 by FACman » Logged

"You can call me by my first name...Sarge."
Rattler
WaT Supporter

*

Offline Offline

Germany

Location: Med Island
Posts: 2214




View Profile WWW
« Reply #6 on: 7 November 2009, 23:15:32 »
ReplyReply

Personally, I think this is what reviews should all be about: Whet your appetite...

Rattler
Logged

"War does not determine who is right, war determines who is left...": The Rattler Way Of Life (thanks! to Solideo)... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9v3Vyr5o2Q
Tanker
Sergeant Major
**

Offline Offline

United States

Posts: 223


View Profile
« Reply #7 on: 8 November 2009, 02:59:13 »
ReplyReply

Some balancing reviews:

This work is a piece of fiction masquerading as investigative scholarhsip. Ms. Jensen's sources are bogus, supporting "evidence" is taken out of context, and she describes events that never happened. I served four years as the Chief of the Defense Intelligence Agency Special Office for Prisoners of War and Missing in Action and two years as Deputy Director of the Defense POW-MIA Office. I am deeply familiar with every incident, source, and story told in this book. The book is nonsense.
By    w4hh@3wave.com (Bristol, TN)

side from its "mysterious" and "too dangerous" so-called sources, the book is full of outright lies. To cite just one example, Jensen makes a very big deal out of the "mysterious" crash of an EC-47. The book claims that the EC-47 was "an aircraft designed to be a death trap" and that the crew was "compelled to commit war crimes." She also claims that "Because of the sophisticated electronic equipment on board, arrangements existed for the immolation and destruction of the aircraft before it could fall into enemy hands. The electronic equipment was packed in so tightly that it was almost impossible for men to bail out." All of that is just plain not true. Not one word of it. Nobody was forced to do anything. I was a navigator instructor on EC-47s at the same base in Thailand. We were just doing a job, and a pretty good one, compared to some of the idiotic schemes tried in SEA. There was plenty of room: more room than flying in coach these days. And the idea of a self-destruct mechanism on an ancient Gooney Bird is just plain laughable. Conspiracy theorists will love this book, but Ms. Jensen only perpetuates the myth that there are POWs still alive, which again would be laughable if it weren't so sad that families are still being used by scam artists like Ms. Jensen.

By    D. Steiner "theatre person" (Allenspark, CO USA)

I'm just skeptical of conspiracy theories.

Logged
FACman
WaT Supporter

*

Offline Offline

United States

Location: Ar-kansas
Posts: 827




View Profile
« Reply #8 on: 8 November 2009, 03:23:50 »
ReplyReply

All opinions of the reviewers aside, I would be hard pressed to disbelieve that the Russians and Chinese did not acquire tech savy pilots and crew members from the Vietnamese. As I previously mentioned, the Vietnamese are known to have used their 'Pearls' for monetary gain. Surely the Russians and Chinese would have paid dearly to get their hands on these valuable assets, as the 'Cold War' was still in full swing during the time in question.

I did post a clip from D. Steiner, I left off the clip wherein the fellow used an e-mail instead of his name. If he is in fact who he says he is and participated in the manner he says, his review is far more subjective than my own, if for no other reason that he has a dog in this fight.
Logged

"You can call me by my first name...Sarge."
Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Unique Hits: 2899416 | Sitemap
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.14 | SMF © 2006-2011, Simple Machines LLC
TinyPortal v0.9.8 © Bloc
Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!


Google visited last this page 18 May 2012, 20:36:45